Ethos Benefits | The Business of Benefits, Episode 88
Learning how to vet benefits vendors has quietly become one of the most valuable skills a CFO or HR leader can build. Cost pressure is real, the pitches are getting more creative, and the line between a genuinely innovative program and an illegal one is not always obvious from the sales deck.
Watch the full conversation: Innovative or Illegal? How to Vet Benefits Vendors on YouTube.
On Episode 88 of The Business of Benefits, Chelsea Ryckis sits down with Chris Vanderwolk, an ERISA attorney who came up through the business before he came to the law. He left the Army, worked as a carrier account manager and sales rep, ran a TPA, and has about twenty years in benefits. As he puts it, unlike a lot of ERISA attorneys, he started in benefits well before law school. He has read the compliance memos, pushed back on the promoters, and watched one program’s promoters go to federal prison. What follows are four tests drawn from that conversation.
Why learning to vet benefits vendors became a board-level question
Start with the number that explains the pressure. According to the KFF 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey, the average annual premium for employer-sponsored family coverage reached $26,993, up 6% in a single year. Single coverage averaged $9,325.
When a line item moves like that, employers go looking for answers. And where employers go looking, vendors follow. Chelsea opens on exactly that, asking why there is suddenly a vendor for everything. Chris splits the field cleanly: there is a real opportunity for innovative things that are compliant, and then there are innovative schemes that are not.
The useful test that falls out of the conversation is not whether a program sounds good. It is whether anyone will tell you plainly what they make money on, what they do not make money on, and how. Chris sets that as the baseline for any partner worth keeping, and it is the first thing to ask when you vet benefits vendors.
The pitch that lands in your inbox
Here is the version Chris hears most often, close to verbatim from the emails midsize employers receive every week:
“Somebody pitches, we take $1,200 pretax, we take a $200 fee from the employee, we take a $50 fee from you, we give your employee back $1,000 a month tax-free because they participate in our program.”
It is usually dressed as a wellness program, a self-insured medical reimbursement plan, or a fixed indemnity arrangement. Every one of these programs carries some level of telemedicine, free generic drugs, or a wellness component. The employee participates, and money comes back tax-free. Everyone saves on payroll taxes. Nobody appears to lose.
One word takes it apart: reimbursement.
Pre-tax contributions are real. Tax-free reimbursement of medical expenses is real. That is how medical plans, HRAs, and FSAs work. Every one of those arrangements requires either a provider paid directly for care or an actual out-of-pocket expense reimbursed. In a double-dip structure, nobody spent anything. There is no expense to reimburse, so the money simply cycles.
The IRS reached the same conclusion in writing. In Chief Counsel Advice 202323006, issued in 2023, the agency examined an employer-funded fixed indemnity policy that paid a flat $1,000 per month whenever an employee completed a wellness activity. Because the payment did not track any actual medical cost, the exclusion under Section 105(b) did not apply. The payments were includible in gross income and were wages for FICA, FUTA, and federal income tax withholding.
The compliance memo a vendor hands you will often walk through all of the real rules accurately, then quietly decline to address the one gap the program depends on. This is the moment where employers who vet benefits vendors carefully separate themselves from employers who sign.
Four tests for how to vet benefits vendors
None of these require a law degree. Each one can be run by a CFO, an HR director, or a benefits committee in an afternoon, and together they are the quickest honest way to vet benefits vendors before anything gets signed.
1. Ask who actually carries the responsibility
Chelsea sets the baseline first. Fiduciary responsibility sits with the plan sponsor, which means the plan sponsor owns the due diligence, the knowledge of a reasonable expert, and a documented process. It does not matter whether the consultant, the broker, the TPA, or the vendor brought the idea in. Chris’s answer is the line that sticks:
“You can delegate authority, but you can’t delegate responsibility. You can have people act for you, but you’re still responsible for picking them and the choices they make.”
So the liability does not travel with the recommendation. Picking the expert is itself one of the choices you are answerable for, which is why the record of how you picked matters as much as the pick.
For most benefits committees, this is the uncomfortable part of any effort to vet benefits vendors. Ask whether anyone has a written record for the vendors added in the last three years. If the answer is no, that is the first gap to close, and it closes with a habit rather than a project.
2. Treat the NDA as the answer
“Some of them will want to make you sign a nondisclosure agreement to get a compliance memo. I would say that should be one of your first red flags, because nobody has a unique ability to operate within the tax code.”
An NDA reads like a signal that what you are about to see is valuable and proprietary. Apply that logic to tax law and it comes apart. The tax code is public, and Chris’s point is that the market as a whole knows how to work in it. The largest firms have more smart people who have spent more time on every loophole in that code than any broker he has known. Nobody can own an interpretation of it. You cannot trademark an interpretation of the tax code, he says. It is or it is not legal.
Chris reads the opacity as deliberate. These programs are hard to understand, he says, because they are intentionally designed to confuse people. An NDA on a compliance memo does the same work from the other direction, by limiting how many trained eyes ever see the document.
3. Run the Big 4 test
“For anything tax-related, are the Big 4 doing this? If they are not, why not?”
This is the fastest way to vet benefits vendors selling a tax position. Ask your accountant whether the major firms use this structure for their own clients. If they do not, find out why not. Sometimes the honest answer is that you are early, and being early is real. The employers who started self-funding fifteen years ago sat well outside the norm, and then everybody else caught up.
But early means the mainstream has not caught up yet. It does not mean thousands of tax professionals read the same code and somehow missed a legal structure that hands employers free money. Chris adds one more filter worth keeping: consider who is selling it. Someone who was selling mortgages and employee retention tax credits three years ago is not who discovers a new provision of the tax code.
4. Price the bundle yourself
ERISA Section 408(b)(2) asks two questions about every fee your plan pays. Is the compensation disclosed, and is it reasonable? The first one most employers can answer. The second they tend to treat as a matter of opinion.
It is not. Reasonable has a benchmark, and the benchmark is what the same services cost on the open market. The Consolidated Appropriations Act extended the fee disclosure requirement to group health plans, and the Department of Labor set out its enforcement approach in Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2021-03. Brokers and consultants expecting $1,000 or more in compensation have to disclose it, and you are entitled to see it.
Chris did the arithmetic out loud. The telemedicine package at the center of these programs prices out at roughly $8 per employee per month. Chelsea’s reaction was that it sounded about right, and her own guess was $5 to $10.
This is the step most employers skip when they vet benefits vendors. Now look at what the promoters take. On the double-dip programs it is $50 per employee per month from the employer and $200 per employee per month from the employee, so $250 a month is leaving the system for a bundle that costs $8.
“The bundle of services, that telemedicine package, you can buy that, and I’ve priced it out. It’s $8 per employee per month. […] So if you’re paying $200 for that, is that reasonable?”
Ask what the rest of that money buys and the answer gets uncomfortable. In Chris’s words, they are just telling you to go and evade taxes, so that is not a reasonable fee. You would never approve a software contract at that multiple without asking why, and your health plan is a bigger line item than your software.
What happens when one of these unwinds
The first scheme that ever landed on Chris’s desk was a program called the Classic 105, run out of Louisiana by The Total Financial Group. The pitch explained that the $1,000 employees received came from a loan they would never have to repay. His question was one sentence long: who is going to issue a loan you never have to pay back?
A broker brought it to him because she was in conversations with a significant city in New Jersey about putting it in. He told her she would end up in jail if she did this. She listened. The promoters kept selling.
In March 2022, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Louisiana announced that the architects of the scheme were sentenced. Denis Joachim received 97 months in federal prison and Donna Joachim received a year and a day. The company collected more than $25.5 million in fees and caused an underpayment of at least $23.3 million in federal FICA taxes.
Read the next line carefully, because it is the one employers miss. The Justice Department described those underpaid amounts as taxes “for which the employer-clients and employee-participants may be individually responsible.”
The promoter is gone. The bill stays.
And it does not land evenly. These programs are often marketed to franchise operators, so you see recognizable brand logos in the materials even though the brand vetted nothing and it was a small franchisee who signed up. The people working there are frequently earning $15 or $20 an hour and spending every dollar that hits the paycheck. When a back tax bill arrives two years later, Chris asks the obvious question: where is that money coming from? And he raises a second question nobody in the sales process asks: what happens to those employees when they go to collect Social Security having under-withheld against what they actually earned?
As he puts it, it is not a victimless crime.
Diligent is just another word for careful
After an hour spent on schemes, prosecutions, and the people left holding the bill, Chris lands somewhere steadier than you might expect:
“If you’re trying to do a good job, you’re probably doing a pretty good job. You need to be diligent, and diligent is just another word for careful. You need to think about what you’re doing, be thoughtful. […] Have a process, write down your decisions, and you’re most of the way there.”
Much of what employers hear about fiduciary duty is sold with fear, and the implied conclusion is always that the standard is unreachable without buying something. Chris says the opposite. Think about what you are doing, be thoughtful, follow a process, and record why you decided what you decided.
That is the reassuring part for anyone who has started to vet benefits vendors properly and found gaps. He goes one step further, with his own hedge attached. In his experience, when a government agency does show up, they tend to be reasonable with a reasonable person trying to do the right thing. That is not a guarantee, he says, but in almost every case he has seen, good people trying to do the right thing get some grace. The FBI does not appear at your door because you checked a wrong box once.
If you are a CFO or HR leader who has been quietly worried you are behind, you are probably closer than you think. What you most likely lack is not sophistication. It is documentation.
Start with the next decision in front of you. The habit that lets you vet benefits vendors well is small. Before the next program goes live, write down three things: what problem it solves, how the vendor gets paid, and what you compared it to. That record is what turns a judgment call into a defensible one, and it is the backbone of the Ethos fiduciary framework we use with every client plan.
If you want the longer version of what plan sponsors owe their participants, our breakdown of ERISA and non-ERISA plans is a useful companion to this one.
Listen to the full episode
Chris Vanderwolk joins Chelsea Ryckis on Episode 88 of The Business of Benefits for the complete conversation on how to vet benefits vendors, including the fee questions to ask your advisor and what good diligence actually looks like.