The Fiduciary Framework™. A business plan for your benefits.

The Ethos Fiduciary Framework™ is a three to five year business plan for your health and welfare benefits, run through four committee meetings a year. Each meeting covers one part of fiduciary oversight: governance, documents and vendors, compliance, and strategy. Every decision is recorded, so your committee can show how and why it decided.

Your benefits get the same plan as the rest of your business: three to five years out, measured every quarter. Your committee sets the goals and tracks the numbers against them. Ethos builds the plan with you, reports against it and keeps the record of every decision.

Why your plan needs a framework.

If your company sponsors a health plan, the people who make decisions about it are fiduciaries under ERISA, and a fiduciary who breaches a duty can be personally liable for the plan’s losses (ERISA § 409). Read what the duty requires.

Prudence is judged on process. The question a court, a regulator or an auditor asks is not whether the plan did well. It is whether the committee looked at the alternatives, followed a sound process and can show it. Most health plans can’t, because their decisions are made once a year at renewal and live in an email thread.

The Fiduciary Framework™ fixes that with a plan, a calendar and a record.

The business plan, in five parts.

Five parts, built in order, each one feeding the next.

  1. Plan goals Agreed For your people For your budget
    Goals for the plan

    What the plan has to do for your people and for your budget, agreed by your committee.

  2. Scorecard target Cost Trend Claims Pharmacy Each measure against the target your committee set
    KPIs and targets

    Cost, trend, claims and pharmacy spend, each measured against a target you set.

  3. Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5 FundingVendorsDesign now
    A three to five year plan

    The direction for funding, vendors and plan design, year by year.

  4. Results vs. target target Q1Q2Q3Q4
    Quarterly reviews

    Results against target, reviewed with your committee every quarter.

  5. Record WhatWhen and why MinutesMeeting 1 DecisionFunding DisclosureVendor FilingAttestation Ready to hand to an auditor, a regulator or your counsel
    Committee record

    Every decision, filed with its minutes.

The record at the bottom of the page sets next year's goals at the top, so the plan builds on itself instead of starting over at renewal.

Four meetings a year.

Each meeting covers one part of fiduciary oversight, so nothing is left to renewal season.

  1. Q1
    Governance and foundationHow decisions get made
    • Committee structure and charter
    • Conflict of interest standards
    • Fiduciary training
    • How vendors are evaluated
  2. Q2
    Documents and vendorsWhat you are paying for
    • Plan documents
    • Vendor contracts
    • Compensation disclosures
    • Vendor due diligence
  3. Q3
    Compliance and regulatory reviewWhat the law requires this year
    • Consolidated Appropriations Act disclosures
    • Transparency rules
    • Annual filings and notices
    • The gag clause attestation
  4. Q4
    Strategy, monitoring and riskWhere the plan is going
    • Funding and plan design
    • Vendor scorecards
    • Cost containment
    • KPIs against target
One plan year, one meeting a quarter. Then the year starts again with the record from the last one, for every year of the three to five year plan.

What your committee gets.

  • A process that repeats. The same cadence every year, so a new committee member can see how decisions are made.
  • A record you can hand to anyone. What was decided, when and why, ready for an auditor, a regulator or your counsel.
  • Accountable vendors. Contracts, compensation and performance reviewed on a schedule, with the due diligence documented.
  • Deadlines owned. Every federal requirement for your health and welfare plans, with an owner, a due date and proof it was done.
  • A strategy instead of a renewal. Decisions made against goals and targets, not against last year’s increase.

Where the record lives.

Every meeting, form and decision is kept in the Ethos Fiduciary OS: the fiduciary file with the committee’s minutes and self-assessment, the compliance calendar, and every plan document, in one place your committee can open at any time.

This page describes ERISA in plain language for employers. It is not legal advice.

Sources

  1. Understanding Your Fiduciary Responsibilities Under a Group Health Plan, U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration
  2. 29 U.S. Code § 1104, fiduciary duties (ERISA § 404), Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  3. 29 U.S. Code § 1109, liability for breach of fiduciary duty (ERISA § 409), Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School

Questions employers ask about this.

Who owns the Fiduciary Framework™ inside our company?

Your benefits committee, usually people from HR and finance, with an executive sponsor. Ethos runs the meetings, prepares the materials and keeps the record, but the committee makes the decisions. Spreading decisions across a documented committee is also better protection for the individuals on it.

How often should a health plan's fiduciary process be reviewed?

At least once a year. The Fiduciary Framework™ meets four times a year, one meeting per quarter, so governance, vendors, compliance and strategy each get a full review instead of being squeezed into renewal season.

What records should health plan fiduciaries keep?

The committee charter and minutes, conflict of interest forms, vendor due diligence and contract reviews, compensation disclosures, compliance filings and notices, and each strategy decision with the numbers behind it. In the Framework, all of it is kept in the Ethos Fiduciary OS.

Can the Framework be reviewed by an auditor or an outside party?

Yes. That is what it is built for. Every meeting, form and decision is recorded with what was decided, when and why, so the record can be handed to an auditor, a regulator or your own counsel.

How long does it take to start?

It starts with the first committee meeting. Ethos sets up the committee structure and charter at that meeting, then builds the rest of the plan and the record over the four meetings of the first year.

Is the Fiduciary Framework™ the same as a renewal?

No. A renewal is one decision a year. The Framework is the business plan the renewal decision fits into, with goals, targets and a record that carry from one year to the next.

See what your plan is really costing you.

A Strategic Analysis starts with your plan documents and your broker agreement, then shows you what your plan costs, where the risk sits, and what a committee would decide with the full picture.