What Does It Mean to Be a Fiduciary of a Health Plan?

February 24, 2025

Being a fiduciary of a health plan is a significant responsibility that comes with legal and ethical obligations. Fiduciaries play a critical role in ensuring that employee health plans are managed in the best interests of plan participants and their beneficiaries. But what does that really mean? Let’s break it down.

Defining a Fiduciary

A fiduciary is someone who exercises discretionary authority or control over a health plan’s management, assets, or administration. This can include employers, HR professionals, or anyone responsible for making decisions about the plan. Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), fiduciaries are held to the highest standard of conduct, known as the “prudent person” standard.

Key Responsibilities of a Fiduciary

Fiduciaries have several core responsibilities to ensure that health plans operate in the best interests of participants:

1. Act Solely in the Interest of Participants

Fiduciaries must prioritize the needs of plan participants and their beneficiaries above all else. This means avoiding conflicts of interest and making decisions that benefit employees rather than the organization or third-party vendors.

2. Follow the Plan Documents

Fiduciaries are required to adhere to the terms outlined in the health plan’s governing documents, provided those terms comply with ERISA regulations. This ensures consistency and fairness in plan administration.

3. Ensure Reasonable Costs

One of the fiduciary’s most critical duties is to ensure that the plan’s costs are reasonable. This involves regularly reviewing vendor contracts, fees, and services to confirm they align with industry standards and provide value to participants.

4. Act Prudently

The “prudent person” standard requires fiduciaries to act with care, skill, and diligence. This includes staying informed about health plan trends, legal requirements, and best practices to make well-informed decisions.

5. Monitor Service Providers

Fiduciaries must continuously monitor third-party administrators, insurers, and other service providers to ensure they are fulfilling their obligations. This includes evaluating performance, costs, and adherence to contractual agreements.

6. Avoid Prohibited Transactions

Fiduciaries must avoid transactions that could result in self-dealing or conflicts of interest. For example, selecting a vendor based on personal relationships rather than merit would violate fiduciary duties.

Why Fiduciary Duty Matters

The fiduciary’s role is critical to maintaining trust and transparency in employee health plans. When fiduciaries act in the best interests of participants, they help ensure that employees receive high-quality benefits at a fair cost. This can lead to improved employee satisfaction, better health outcomes, and reduced financial strain on both employees and the organization.

Consequences of Breaching Fiduciary Duty

Failing to meet fiduciary obligations can have serious consequences, including:

Legal Liability: Fiduciaries can be held personally liable for plan losses resulting from breaches of duty.
Regulatory Penalties: ERISA violations can result in fines and other penalties.
Reputational Damage: A breach of fiduciary duty can erode employee trust and harm the organization’s reputation.

Best Practices for Fiduciaries

To fulfill fiduciary responsibilities effectively, consider these best practices:

Educate Yourself: Stay informed about ERISA requirements, industry trends, and emerging risks.
Document Decisions: Keep detailed records of decisions and the rationale behind them to demonstrate compliance with fiduciary standards.
Engage Experts: Work with trusted advisors, such as benefits consultants or legal counsel, to navigate complex decisions.
Regularly Review the Plan: Conduct periodic audits of plan performance, costs, and compliance to ensure alignment with fiduciary duties.

Final Thoughts

Being a fiduciary of a health plan is more than just a title—it’s a commitment to protecting the interests of employees and their families. By acting with integrity, diligence, and transparency, fiduciaries can ensure that health plans provide meaningful value and meet the highest standards of care.

More Blogs from Ethos