ERISA Bond vs. Fidelity Bond: Key Differences, Requirements, and Fiduciary Implications

ERISA and Fidelity bonds are important tools for ensuring regulatory compliance and protecting against financial risk.

For plan sponsors, common mistakes include assuming that a standard fidelity bond meets ERISA requirements, using a bond that fails to meet Department of Labor (DOL) requirements, and failing to account for plan asset growth over time.

These pitfalls often trigger DOL audits and penalties.

Our ERISA bond vs. fidelity bond walks you through the difference between the two, what each covers, and how to stay compliant.

TL;DR - ERISA Bond vs. Fidelity Bond

ERISA and Fidelity bonds both offer protection against financial losses, but they are distinct.

Here is a quick overview:

ERISA Bond	Fidelity Bond
A mandatory type of fidelity bond that protects your plan assets against acts of fraud or dishonesty	A general bond that protects your business from financial losses due to dishonesty by employees
Pros	Pros
Protect plan assets from losses resulting from fraud and dishonesty. Ensures compliance with Department of Labour requirements to prevent penalties.	Protects the losses to the company assets, not just the plan. Not required by law, so it can be customized for the specific coverage amount, duration, and employee roles.
Cons	Cons
Non-compliance attracts penalties from DOL. Limited to fraud and dishonesty acts by plan handlers.	Can leave a plan non-compliant because it doesn’t automatically meet ERISA bonding requirements. May not cover all plan asset handlers, as coverage is structured around select employees.
Best For	Best For
Plans required by law to meet ERISA regulatory compliance, with multiple plan asset handlers.	Plans that are not subject to ERISA or that exceed the ERISA bond statutory limits.

Most organizations need ERISA bonds to meet federal requirements and fidelity bonds to protect against potential losses from theft.

However, you need to meet your fiduciary responsibility as well.

Ethos Benefits is an employee benefits consulting firm that provides fiduciary oversight to ensure your plans comply with ERISA bonding requirements. We operate with a fiduciary mindset, obligated to act in your company’s best interest.

We simplify the complexities of your employee plans, from lowering your premium costs to planning your plan renewals.

Schedule your discovery call to help ensure your bond coverage aligns with your plan’s structure and regulatory expectations.

What is an ERISA Bond?

An ERISA fidelity bond is a specialized insurance policy required under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.

An ERISA bond must be obtained from surety companies approved by the Department of the Treasury. Your preferred surety provider should be listed in Treasury Department Circular 570.

Who is Required to Have an ERISA Bond

Everyone who handles the assets of an employee benefit plan must be bonded under ERISA, including fiduciaries, trustees, and third-party administrators.

They must be bonded if they have:

Handle plan assets documentation.
Authority to transfer or distribute the plan assets.
Process contributions or authorize the plan to issue cash or checks.

ERISA Bond Coverage

The ERISA bond coverage details are as follows:

It protects an employee benefit plan against losses caused by fraud or dishonesty by individuals who handle plan funds.
Some of the covered acts include theft, embezzlement, forgery, or misappropriation of plan assets.
The bond is designed to protect the plan participants, not the employer or fiduciaries personally.

How ERISA Bond Amounts Are Determined

Here’s a clear breakdown on how to determine the ERISA bond amounts:

ERISA Uses the 10% Rule: Your bond amount is based on 10% of the plan assets handled in your previous plan year. For example, if you handled (received, disbursed, transferred, or had authority) over $500,000 in plan assets, then the minimum bond will be $50,000
Minimum Bond Requirement: ERISA requires a minimum bond value of $1,000 per plan.
Maximum Bond Limit: ERISA imposes strict limits on bond amounts, with a maximum of $500,000 per plan or $1,000,000 for retirement plans that hold the company’s stock.

Note: If your plan assets change significantly, you should update the bond amount to cover the increased assets.

ERISA Bond Requirements and Compliance Rules

If you manage 401(k) and other retirement plan assets, 29 U.S.C. § 1112 of ERISA mandates that anyone who handles employee benefit plans be bonded against fraud, dishonesty, and theft.

Under the DOL, here’s a quick overview of the rules on who needs to be bonded and the bond amount:

States that the bond amount should not be less that 10% of the funds handled and should be at least $1,000.
Mentions that the bond must cover individuals who handle the plan assets.
States that the bond amount must be enough to cover the risks.

Understanding ERISA requirements and using an ERISA compliance checklist are key to properly managing your plan assets.

Fiduciary Consequences of ERISA Bond Non-Compliance

Non-compliance with the ERISA bond has serious regulatory and fiduciary consequences.

Let’s discuss them below:

Personal Liability: If losses on a plan arise from fraud or dishonesty, the fiduciaries may be held liable to reimburse the plan.
DOL Scrutiny: The DOL may request proof of your ERISA bond compliance during audits. If the bond is missing or inaccurate, they may impose corrective actions and warnings.
Civil Penalties: ERISA bond non-compliance can increase employees’ lawsuits and defense costs.
Financial Loss: Without an ERISA Bond, you’re unprotected against theft or fraud, which can result in loss of funds and increased legal risk for the plan.

What is a Fidelity Bond?

A standard fidelity bond protects your business and clients against financial losses arising from employee dishonesty or fraudulent acts.

What Does a Fidelity Bond Cover?

Typically, the fidelity bond covers criminal financial misconduct by employees, including:

Theft
Fraudulent fund transfers
Misappropriation of funds
Forgery or alteration of financial instruments, such as checks.

How Does a Fidelity Bond Work?

The fidelity bond is activated when an employee commits a dishonest or fraudulent act, such as embezzlement.

Once a verified claim of employee action is made, the insurer investigates and reimburses the company for losses up to the policy limit.

Who Typically Needs a Fidelity Bond

Any business that handles clients’ funds or company property must protect against employee theft and dishonesty.

These include employee plan sponsors, financial Institutions, government contractors, collection agencies, licensed professionals, property management companies, and hospitality businesses.

Fidelity Bond vs. ERISA Bond: Core Differences

The two bonds differ in structure, scope, and the individuals they cover.

Below is a table comparing them against these aspects:

	Fidelity Bond	ERISA Bond
Bond Amount	No specific threshold. Determined by the number of employees, industry, and the employer’s risk assessment.	Set at a minimum of 10% of plan assets being handled, up to a maximum of $1 million
Scope	It can cover employee theft, forgery, and dishonesty, and it’s not limited to the plan assets	Only covers losses due to fraud and dishonesty of the plan assets
Bonded individuals	Covers employees named in the policy and might not include all plan assets unless specified	Must include all individuals who handle plan assets
Insured party	The company assets	The plan assets

Similarities and Differences

Let’s look at how these two compare:

ERISA Bond and Fidelity Bond Differences

The difference between the two lies in what is covered and the regulatory requirements:

An ERISA bond protects the plan assets, while a fidelity bond protects the company assets.
A Treasury-approved surety must issue an ERISA bond, whereas a fidelity bond has no Treasury requirements.
An ERISA bond is mandatory for all ERISA-covered plans, while a fidelity bond is an optional protection for business assets.

ERISA Bond and Fidelity Bond Similarities

Despite their differences, these two bonds share some similarities:

They both cover losses resulting from fraud or other dishonest acts.
They both demand proper documentation and verification during claim processing.
They do not cover losses arising from intentional acts, such as poor investment decisions, operational errors, or poor judgment.

How to Assess ERISA Bond Compliance and Risk Exposure

Here are 5 steps to assess your ERISA bond compliance:

Confirm the Bond Meets ERISA Requirements: Review if your bond complies with ERISA Section 412 and whether the plan is named as the insured. Also, confirm that a Treasury-approved surety company issues the bond.
Verify the Coverage Amount: Assess the prior plan year’s total plan assets to ensure compliance with ERISA bond statutory minimums and caps. You should also verify whether the plan asset growth has outpaced your bond coverage and whether the securities held are triggering a higher cap.
Identify All Fiduciaries: The coverage should name all plan administrators, trustees, employees, and third-party service providers that handle plan assets to ensure there are no compliance gaps, even if the bond amount is correct.
Review Renewals: The ERISA bond must remain effective at all times, including during renewals and plan asset changes. You should check for any gaps, such as incorrect coverage amounts and new administrators that need to be identified. If it’s an automatic renewal, it should adjust these coverage limits.
Maintain Documentation: You should demonstrate compliance by maintaining bond calculations, renewal records, coverage schedules, and evidence of annual compliance reviews.

The Role of Fiduciary Oversight in Bond Compliance

Fiduciary oversight ensures your benefits plan complies with applicable laws and regulations.

Ethos Benefits is a fiduciary employee benefits consultant. We act in your company’s interests under ERISA and to ensure bond compliance.

Here’s what we do:

Ongoing Auditing: With a fiduciary oversight, nothing falls through the cracks. We conduct employee plan audits to identify any compliance gaps.
Bonding Compliance: The fiduciary approach is to proactively review your compliance requirements during your plan design and renewal.
Administration Support: Beyond ERISA bond compliance, managing your employee plan benefits is complex. We guide your team in technology integration, employee eligibility, and communication.
Plan Transparency: To comply with ERISA bond requirements, you must maintain accurate, transparent documentation of your plan assets. As fiduciary advisors, we help clients with clear asset documentation that reduces risk during DOL audits and maintains compliance records.

We design plans that align with your company’s interests while remaining compliant with applicable federal and state requirements. We operate on a transparent, flat-fee model with no surprise costs.

Schedule a discovery call today to help ensure compliance with your employees’ plans.

The Bottom Line

As we’ve seen, the ERISA bond protects plan assets, must include employees who handle plan assets, and has a $500,000 per-plan limit. On the other hand, a fidelity bond protects company assets, covers the employees named in the policy, and you set the bond amount.

If you want to ensure your benefits plan meets your company’s goals and ERISA compliance requirements, you should work with an expert.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are some concerns raised by most employers:

Does an ERISA Bond Satisfy Fidelity Bond Requirements?

Although the ERISA bond is a type of fidelity bond, it doesn’t satisfy the fidelity bond requirements because:

It protects plan assets, not business assets.
The ERISA bond amount caps at $500,000 per plan.
It includes only employees who handle plan assets.

Can a Fidelity Bond Cover Independent Contractors?

Yes, through a third-party fidelity bond, you can protect your business against intentional mismanagement acts by independent contractors.

Are ERISA Bond Costs Tax Deductible for Employers?

Yes, ERISA bond costs are tax-deductible for employers and treated as business expenses under Section 162 of the Internal Revenue Code.

WEBINAR